What is smuggling of persons in Texas?
Smuggling of persons in Texas is the state law on alien smuggling. Specifically, Tex. Pen. Code § 20.05 makes it a crime to smuggle humans. Also, § 20.05 raises the jail time if anyone is hurt or killed during the crime.
Of major interest, § 20.05 bans different ways to smuggle people. First, § 20.05 makes it a crime to use a car, boat, airplane, or other vehicle to intentionally:
- Hide a person from police; or
- Flee from police.
Stated differently, it is a crime to drive to the border to pickup aliens.
Next, § 20.05 makes it a crime to knowingly:
- Encourage people to enter the country;
- Hide, harbor, or protect people from being caught by police; and
- Help two or more people to enter or remain on farm land without the owner’s permission.
However, § 20.05 is controversial. This is because § 20.05 is cloned from 8 USC § 1324. Consequently, Texas and federal law overlap and conflict. This raises an important question: “Can Texas prosecute immigration crimes in state court?”
Our post will answer this question. In addition, we will also show you how § 20.05 works. Finally, we will show you a legal way to fight a smuggling of persons charge.
What are examples of smuggling of persons in Texas?
Examples of smuggling of persons include:
- Picking up aliens near the border and driving them to San Antonio, Houston, or Dallas;
- Operating a stash house; or
- Entering into a deal with others to drive aliens from the border to major cities.
Furthermore, driving aliens from the border to major cities is the most common way police arrest someone for human smuggling.
To explain, cartels need drivers to move people from the border to major cities. So the cartels advertise on social media. The ads offer “fast cash,” “easy money,” and “clean routes.” This attracts drivers from all over Texas to drive to the border to pick up people.
Nonetheless, police know about these ads. And they know the routes smugglers use to move people. So they scout these roads and look for telltale signs of human smuggling. From there, police stop the car and arrest the driver for smuggling of persons.
What are facts that can increase the jail time for smuggling of persons in Texas?
You may get extra jail time if:
- You get into a high speed chase with police
- You hide people in the trunk of your car;
- The person smuggled is a child;
- You smuggle people for money;
- You carry or hold a gun during the crime;
- Someone raped the smuggled person during the crime; or
- The smuggled person is hurt badly or killed during the crime.
What are the penalties for smuggling of persons in Texas?
|Tex. Pen. Code||Felony Type||Aggravating Facts||Penalty||Fine|
|§20.05(b)||Third Degree||None.||2-10 years in TDC.|
|Up to $10,000.00.|
|§20.05(b)(1)||Second Degree||1. Creates a substantial risk that the smuggled person will suffer serious bodily injury or death;|
2. The smuggled person is a child under 18 years of age at the time of the offense;
3. The offense was committed with the intent to obtain a pecuniary benefit;
4. The defendant or another party to the crime possessed a firearm; or
5. The smuggler flees from police during the offense.
|2-20 years in TDC.|
|Up to $10,000.00.|
|§20.05(b)(2)||First Degree||1. As a direct result of the offense, the smuggled individual became a victim of sexual assault or aggravated sexual assault; or|
2. The smuggled individual suffered serious bodily injury or death.
|5-99 years or life in TDC. |
* Probation Possible.
|Up to $10,000.00.|
Table: Smuggling of Persons Jail Time.Texas Penal Code § 20.05 is the state law on human smuggling. It is similar to 8 USC § 1324, which is the federal law on alien smuggling. But there are also important differences between these two laws.
One key difference is that 8 USC § 1324 requires the smuggled person to be an alien. Conversely, § 20.05 does not require the smuggled person to be an alien. This means that under state law it is technically possible to smuggle U.S. Citizens.
Additionally, under Texas law, a person sent to prison for smuggling of persons is eligible for parole. But a person convicted of alien smuggling in federal court is not eligible for parole. This is because parole does not exist in the federal system. Instead, that person in federal court will get a term of supervised release after he completes his jail term.
To add to that, supervised release blends the worst parts of parole and probation. It requires the defendant to serve the majority or all of the jail term in federal prison. Once the person completes the federal jail term, the judge puts him on supervised release. If the person violates the terms of supervised release, then he can go back to jail.
These are just a few of the ways Texas and federal human-smugglings laws are different and appear to conflict. Notably, these differences are red flags that indicate Tex. Penal Code § 20.05 may be unconstitutional. We will explore this idea below.
What happens after I am arrested for smuggling of persons in Texas?
Also, many of these arrests are happening in rural counties at or near the border. The end result is that you may have to go to court in a county that is hundreds of miles away from your hometown.
To make matters worse, many of these counties are setting high bond amounts. In some cases, bonds can be $35,000 to $50,000 per count. This will cause you to pay large cash amounts to bond out jail. This is especially true if you are charged with more than one count.
Nevertheless, if this happens to you, then you have options. Your attorney can ask the judge to lower the bond amount. He can do this by filing a writ of habeas corpus. The judge will then decide if the bond should be lowered.
On the other hand, if you cannot afford any bond amount and are stuck in jail, then you can ask the judge to lower your bond after 90 days. This happens if the state is not ready for trial within 90 days. If this is the case, then the judge can either lower your bond or release you on a PR bond.
Does Operation Lone Star conflict with Federal Immigration laws?
Tex. Pen. Code § 20.05 pushes the legal boundaries. However, to see why, we first need to look at how Operation Lone began. After that, we can look at the problems this law is causing.
On March 6, 2021, Texas Governor Greg Abbott launched “Operation Lone Star.” This is the State of Texas’s response to the high number of illegal border crossings along the Texas-Mexico border. Stated differently, Operation Lone Star is a political act.
In contrast, Operation Lone Star turns this system upside down. State troopers are making alien smuggling arrests. And they are filing these cases in state court. This takes us back to our opening question: Can Texas prosecute people for immigration crimes in state court?
This is an open question. The law is not clear on this point. But there is a strong argument that Operation Lone Star is unconstitutional. Chiefly, this argument is based on the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution.
Supremacy Clause vs. Operation Lone Star.
Article VI of the U.S. Constitution says that in many areas or fields, federal law is the “supreme law of the land.” This gives Congress the power to stop states from passing laws that conflict with federal law. To be sure, immigration law is a key area that Congress controls.
As a result, it appears that Operation Lone Star goes too far. It gives DPS the power to enforce its own version of federal immigration law. Worse yet, the penalties for smuggling of persons conflict with 8 USC § 1324.
This is because in many ways, the state law carries stiffer penalties than federal law. As an example, if a person smuggles a minor, he will face between 0-10 years in jail under 8 USC § 1324. On the other hand, he will face between 2-20 years in jail under Tex. Pen. Code. § 20.05.
In sum, Texas and federal law conflict on human smuggling penalties. More importantly, human smuggling is traditionally a federal and not a state crime. In other words, only DOJ can file and prosecute alien smuggling crimes.
Smuggling of Persons in Texas Defense.
For these reasons, if DPS arrests you for smuggling of persons under Operation Lone Star, you should consider filing a motion to dismiss based on the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution. You may have a solid defense by raising this issue with the judge in your case. Finally, you can file this motion even if there is no doubt that you were smuggling people.